Terminology – Page 3 – Hadith Answers

What do you mean by: Good/reliable?

Question

When you say the chain for a certain Hadith is ‘reliable’ or ‘good’ – does this mean it’s Hasan or authentic?

The ruling of fabricated narrations

Question

What is the ruling regarding mawdu’ (fabricated) narrations? Can we act upon a mawdu’ Hadith?

Chapters found in a Jami'

Question

As I understand, in order for a Hadith work to be classified as a Jami’, it must contain 8 topics.

viz.

1. Aqaid, 2. Ahkam, 3. Tarikh/Siyar, 4. Tafseer, 5. Manaqib, 6. Adaab, 7. Fitan.

My question is regarding the eighth topic. Some say it is Ashratus sa’ah, and others say Riqaq.

My understanding is that Ashratus sa’ah is included within Fitan thus making Riqaq the eight topic. However, due to some scholar not mentioning riqaq, and seperating fitan from ashratus sa’ah, I wanted to get some information regarding it.

JazakAllah Khayr.

The difference between mawdu’ (fabrications) & extremely weak Hadiths

Question

How is a mawdu’ Hadith different from da’if jiddan?

I have read from ulama that there are some scholars who hold the position of narrating anything so long as its not fabricated.

Can you please name some of these scholars?

The strict rules of the Hadith Masters

Question

I once heard in a lecture that the scholars of the past were very strict on grading the authenticity of the narrators of hadith.

The lecturer stated that there are some narrators who were graded as weak because they were seen eating while walking.

Also, some narrator was deemed weak because he was seen eating in public. Is this true? Would you be able to name the narrator who was deemed weak because of eating in public? Is there a reason for this other than it might make others desire the same food? Jazakallah.

Ruling on untraceable Hadiths

Question

I have read that some Hadiths are untraceable. What is the ruling on stories and Hadiths that cannot be found?

Should such Hadiths be propagate or abstinence be kept.

Jazakallah kayran for your efforts.

Question regarding the chapters in Sahih Muslim

Question

I read a book that mentions that it was the habit of early Muhaddithun to write very little of their own commentary and usually their books were filled with mainly the wordings of the Rasulullah (sallallahu’alayhi wasallam). So much so that Imam Muslim (rahimahullah) did not even write a muqaddimah (introduction) and did not even mention any headings of the chapters (tarajim).

But the copies which we have today do have both; the muqaddimah (intro) as well as the Titles of the chapters (tarajimul abwab).

Could you kindly clarify and exhibit some light on this issue?

Imam Bukhari's terminology: 'fihi nazr'

Question

Respected Moulana, What is meant when Imam Bukhari (rahimahullah) says the following regarding a narrator?

‘fihi nazrun’ فيه نظر or ‘Fi Hadithi nazrun'” في حديثه نظر

Jazakallahu khayran.

What is Riwayatul Hadith & Dirayatul Hadith?

Question

What is Dirayatul-Hadith or ilmul-Hadith dirayah ?

How is it different from ilmul-Hadith riwayah?

Are all the Hadiths transmitted with their exact wording?

Question

I heard, that the Hadiths in general are not transmitted to their exact wording, but that the Sahaba just transmitted it according to meaning and not according to the exact wording. Is this true?