Home | Latest Answers | The book Admonishment of the neglectful

The book Admonishment of the neglectful

Question

I have a kitab called Admonishment of the neglectful, it is the translation of the kitab Tanbihul ghafilin. Is it an authentic kitab and can I teach this kitab to others?

 

Answer

This kitab has all types of narrations, of which many are even declared as fabrications by the Muhaddithun.

Refer: Siyar A’lamin Nubala, vol.16 pg.322-323 and Al-Musannafatul lati takallama ‘alayhal Imamu Dhahabi, vol.2 pg.761.

 

One who can differentiate between the acceptable Hadiths and the non acceptable ones, may read/teach the kitab whilst avoiding the fabrications.

 

 

And Allah Ta’ala Knows best,

 

Answered by: Moulana Muhammad Abasoomar