Question

If a Hadith is graded da’if (weak) by some Muhaddithun and mawdu’ (fabricated) by other Muhaddithun, how do you reconcile between the two?

 

Answer

This depends on the surrounding circumstances of that Hadith as well as the Muhaddithun who have graded it. Hence, each case will be resolved accordingly.

Kindly refer to the following link for a discussion on such differences of opinion:
https://al-miftah.com/intricacies-in-hadith-grading/

 

And Allah Ta’ala Knows best.

 

Answered by: Moulana Muhammad Abasoomar